Column: The curse of singing journalists, atbp.

Today’s column. Considering my many friends in the ABS-CBN newsroom, not exactly easy to write. But as one of them pledged, All is fair indeed in love and war. Published on January 5, 2010.

I CAN’T GET IT OUT OF MY HEAD, RUNS ONE typical comment in one of the many available YouTube versions. Watching ABS-CBN’s “Ako ang Simula” music video, we can easily see why. It is catchy, powerful, unforgettable. It is also wrong.

It blurs, in the name of good citizenship, the already heavily smudged line between journalism and entertainment.

I have many friends in the ABS-CBN newsroom, and its trio of leaders—Maria Ressa, Charie Villa and Glenda Gloria—I both know and admire. I am also quite aware that, under Maria’s management, the ABS-CBN newsroom has fought a difficult but largely successful battle to recover its sense of professionalism after the vertigo of the Estrada years. I have also written, in this space and elsewhere, about seeing this sense of professionalism at work in ABS-CBN and its cable showcase, ABS-CBN News Channel. (I have enjoyed the opportunity to think, or mumble, on air, as a guest of several shows on ANC.)

One more thing: I know the tireless Arlene Burgos and like both the premise and the conduct of the Boto Mo Patrol Mo campaign she manages for the network, and which is directly related, as source to water, to the “Ako ang Simula” (I am the Beginning, or It Begins with Me) music video.

It is for these reasons that I found their singing-acting participation in the video deeply upsetting.

Watching the video the first time several weeks ago, I had a vague sense of unease. I was swept away by the visual narrative, but something held me back. It took several random viewings before I could put my finger on it. Then it hit me: The video makes no distinction between the tres Marias and other news journalists, who all can be seen and heard singing, and the professional singers, like the inimitable Bayang Barrios, who punctuate the video. Perhaps that was, in fact, the point of it all. But this inclusiveness is dangerous, because it sends the message that journalism is a mere subset of  entertainment.

Let me be even more specific. I realized, over time, that I was disturbed by the images of my friends and colleagues taking part in the video as singers or actors—and even more upset that their participation was entirely unnecessary. Would the music video have worked without Charie hunched on the train and humming, without Pia Hontiveros leading a chorus of other journalists, without Maria and Glenda singing and staring directly into the camera? I think so.

Obviously, the decision was made, perhaps by the director (Paolo Villaluna) or the executive producer (my colleague-in-columny Pat Evangelista), to include the journalists in the song-and-dance too. (I’m not sure if I want to know what the reasoning process was like.)

But the ABS-CBN network has already come under fire for the celebrity news shows it airs every night and on weekends. These shows deal largely in faux or manufactured news; more damaging from the point of view of an emerging democracy, they devour scarce time and resources that could have gone to feed legitimate news programs.

There’s the rub. The “Ako ang Simula” music video is a product of this same entertainment culture. It not only treats the news anchors like the mass media celebrities they are; it treats even news executives as though they were entertainers too. Indeed, and here for me lies indisputable proof, over the Christmas holidays the music video was easily mistaken for the network’s traditional celebrity-driven plug. (We can also ask ourselves, Did Ed Murrow sing for CBS?)

“Ako ang Simula,” it seems to me, is a dead end for Philippine journalism.

 * * *

Newsroom thoughts at the start of a new year: Hedley Donovan succeeded Henry Luce as Time editor in chief, and it was under his management that Time reached the peak of its journalistic reputation. In 1989, he wrote a characteristically self-effacing memoir, the first chapter of which listed a handful of “working rules” in “managing the unmanageable”—that is, the “intellectuals” (very broadly defined; he could have used “creatives” and the effect would have been the same) who constituted the Time group’s most important assets. Two excerpts:

“Bossing intellectuals is a high calling: The individual who undertakes this job is seeking to organize/improve/protect an environment in which creative people can do something close to their best work. Creative people may not always be so grateful as their boss thinks they should be. All the many ways that employees can be suspicious, resentful, or critical of the boss are accentuated when the employees are intellectuals. They can be temperamental, cantankerous … But it is still true that one of the greatest possible executive satisfactions is to feel you have helped bring out or bring along an intellectual talent. Sensitively managed, even large and complex organizations can stimulate and liberate creative individuals.”

“Don’t be stingy with criticism: It goes without saying that the manager must be generous with praise, but the judicious application of criticism to very touchy people is more challenging work. There are three messages that must be implicit in successful criticism of intellectuals. First, you can do better work than this; in fact, some of this is very good; I just wish more of it were as good as the best of it. Second, the same standards are being applied to your peers. And last, I myself want to be held, by you and others, to these standards.”

Advertisements

4 Comments

Filed under Newsstand: Column, Readings in Media

4 responses to “Column: The curse of singing journalists, atbp.

  1. Gej

    Upsetting and disturbing indeed. Add to that advertisements for network shows/telenovelas masqueraded as news. And it’s not only ABS-CBN that is guilty of this.

  2. Ezra Muehler

    This is a joke!
    People are reacting http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dlFLPt_B4EA

  3. yes, it is sooo dead an end for philippine journalism. sila daw ang simula ng pagbabago. pagbabago sa pamamagitan ng pagpatrol ng boto. napakababaw na pagbabago. i wish abs-cbn were more seriously interested in raising the bar for candidates and the voting public alike in the coming elections not through mtv type productions like this but with talk shows where issues can be intelligently and objectively discussed and the public can learn something instead of just being entertained, if entertained at all.

  4. twitums

    korekkkk Angela philippine journalism is so dead ! these people are obviously more interested in raising the bar of their CLOUT for their PERSONAL agendas…. Magpa POGI, to seem believable and have a leverage to cover up their unethical behaviors .. We filipinos should be more wary of journalist with a criminal mind bec they directly manipulate goverment officials, justice department to defraud private individuals, in exchange for media mileage … they are worst than any politician, blabbing about code of ethics to seem ethical… actually press release lang sila…HR should check authenticity of credentials and psychological clearance ng mga head, baka me sinto sinto sa loob na naka bola at naging head ….. tsk tsk tsk delikado sa bayan yan kung sila ang maging Simula.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s